22 comments

Fashion Blogging vs. Magazines: What Does The Future Hold?

IFB » Fashion World and Fashion News » Fashion Blogging vs. Magazines: What Does The Future Hold?

Fashion Blogging vs Magazines

As fashion magazines continue to reach out to fashion bloggers more and more, whether it be to form networks (like Lucky), or to use their street style photographs (like W magazine), or write columns (like Garance Dore for French Vogue), I began to wonder: will this progression continue to meld together, eventually evolving digital magazine platforms and blogs into one? Or will magazines and blogs forever be of two different mindsets in fashion?

We recently bumped into some of our favorite editors and bloggers at the Ohne Titel show during New York Fashion Week and asked for their input on topic.

“I think that blogging is just a fresh perspective,” said Kate Lanphear, the style director of US Elle. She believes that blogging is just another filter to look at fashion, much like a buyer, or an editor. In her opinion, it's just another eye.

“Many people predicted magazines will die. I don't think they will die, I think they will evolve.” But as they evolve, what will be the difference between bloggers and digital editors? “When I go to Fashion Week, I may have 2,000 pictures of shoes. I then pick out the 6 pair that I think are really it. Bloggers can post immediately. They serve a different purpose.”

Leandra Medine of the Man Repeller agrees that blogs and magazines will continue to evolve, but on different paths, “I think it will be two separate things. I don't know if magazines are going to be consumed in the same medium that they are being consumed in now, but the fashion magazine will always be one thing, and fashion blogs will be another. That's not to say that both will change because they will tremendously, but I think they will always be two separate teams on fashion.” And what is that difference? “Reading fashion from a person like yourself's point of view is something really special, and I think it's great that fashion blogging is letting everyone feel like an insider.”

“I think that they will always be separate entities. But I think some magazines will probably develop their online arm, so that in the end their online website maybe becomes even stronger than their print magazine,” said Susie Bubble, “and blogs are becoming publishing entities all by themselves.”

What do you think about the evolution of magazines and fashion blogs? Do you think they will someday join forces or will they always be considered completely different platforms?

22 Responses

Sapphire Kharyzma September 11, 2012

I view them as one in the same — as I am speaking from the experience of working in both ends! I agree — magazines won’t die out, but rather transform…becoming more hip and instantaneous — in light of our digital revolution!!!

Reply
Caity @ Moi Contre La Vie September 11, 2012

This is a great piece and such an interesting, forward-looking topic. I agree with Leandra that both mediums will evolve but continue to exist. Fashion magazines, whether they’re paper or online, are aimed at selling & advertizing & making money. And while a fashion blog can sell, have ads, and/or make money, they’re more about a shared passion for fashion.

Reply
Afro Boudoir September 11, 2012

I agree that the two will continue in one form or another but that print will start to concentrate a lot more on their online offering. I’ve recently been asked to write a beauty blog for Hello! magazine – five years ago that never would have happened! I foresee a lot more of that happening; access to the blogger’s audience for the print publication, and exposure and credentials for the blogger. A win, win. Or at least I hope so!

Reply
moiminnie September 11, 2012

I don’t think blogs could ever be considered as a substitute to a printed magazine. Because at the moment, blogs are mainly categorized into personal blogs, fashion, lifestyle, architecture, photography…. And when you buy Vogue, you have it all in one. I think that’s the main advantage of the printed publications.
http://www.moiminnie.blogspot.com
xx

.

Reply
flyycoast2coast September 11, 2012

As a reader of magazines, writer for one, and future owner of my own it is my belief that they will shift into being something more than what we are used to currently. Combining digital and print is necessary in this age but I also think its important not to lose the original form.

L. Camille
stay FLYY. live FLYYER.

Reply
Stylester September 12, 2012

I agree with Susie Bubble – Blogs have become their own publisher entities with bloggers easily transitioning into authors and independent print publishers. Some examples are Scott Schuman’s coffee table book and Leandra Medine’s upcoming book. Blogs represent a collective conciousness with a distinct multifaceted personality that rivals the personality of fashion magazines.

Reply
Cynthia September 12, 2012

Magazines aren’t going to die out. Most of us rely either on friends or a tripod and remote for our personal outfit pictures and no matter how good our friends are, they’ll never be as good as those who shoot for magazines unless they’re professional photographers themselves – even if they spend thousands of dollars on a full-frame camera and software like Lightroom.

http://thecloset.delectablychic.com
http://www.shorty-stories.com

Reply
Rhythm and Ruffle September 12, 2012

I personally think fashion bloggers will eventually have to expand their blogs into full websites. While staying true to the individual blogger – there will be a balance between lifestyle and fashion, etc – focused on the whole person, somewhat like their own reality show online. The print magazine is surely going to take a more (possibly exclusive) digital form, so the choice will be for example: blog/ website or vogue.com. It may be surprising to see in a few years which one gets the click.

Reply
Kimberly September 13, 2012

I still love magazines, because I’ve always preferred that format a bit more than the personal style blogging format, but recently I’ve started to feel that I find more inspiration, and learn more about current trends, through the internet via not just blogs but social networking sites. You can access it anytime and stay updated more frequently this way, plus it’s closer to my target customers.
http://oohlaluxe.net

Reply
petite September 13, 2012

Magazines won’t ever die but become it will become more integrated with digital. Sure some will close but with any type of media you read, you’re accessing it because you like the style or you like the writing. It’s only once the quality ceases to exist and your attitudes change will you turn elsewhere for your information.

In regards to fashion specifically, print will always have a place as long as magazines have a means to go ahead with high quality production. In terms of fashion news, I don’t even bother reading it from a magazine – my twitter feed gave me the low down days ago.
http://petitestreet.net

Reply
Emily Ulrich September 15, 2012

I agree completely. If anything, blogs need magazines as magazines need blogs. They may help each other to progress and retrieve insight from, but that doesn’t mean one will be engulfed by the other’s market completely. There’s a strong relationship, but a definitive line. I see magazines serving a different purpose than bloggers.

Reply
fashionbysai September 15, 2012

This is a nice topic! Just recently one of the premiere fashion magazines here in the Philippines featured bloggers and even made them their magazine cover. I agree that fashion magazines will evolve and that fashion blogging serves a different purpose. I can say that blogging is more real-time than magazines.

Reply
Gabrielle September 15, 2012

I don’t think blogs could ever replace magazines. They are completely different , magazines are put together so meticulously and take so much time to produce an image and to perfect their content you could not compare the two . Magazines are a compilation of different ideas and opinions where as blog are usually administrated by one person with their opinions , so the content in magazines is bound to be more diverse. Blogs are more a personal view of fashion than magazines are.
www.whatwouldwangdo.wordpress.com

Reply
Amit Anand September 16, 2012

While blogging is instant.. magazines are constant.. both will remain important as digitization becomes the norm, both will evolve for the better but would hold on their distinctiveness nonetheless! I see a bright future in fashion videos over fashion editorials – both from a blogging and print perspective.. i.e. moving pictures over static ones!

Reply
Dea Win September 22, 2012

I totally agree with this article. Blogs are making magazines step up!

Reply
Arina George September 24, 2012

Hey…Very cool site!! Good topic of discussion you dig out.I will bookmark the site .I’m happy to locate numerous useful info here within the post.Thank you for sharing.

Reply
Catherine March 6, 2013

It’s pretty clear that magazines will evolve. They have to evolve. The bigger question is how? I don’t think there was a clear answer or clear perspective from the bloggers and editors interviewed in this article. Of course they’ll integrated digitally. Everyone is. But this makes them more like blogs, not less. Shouldn’t the bigger magazines have a better perspective of their landscape and what they need to evolve to? They either don’t know yet or don’t want to show their concern. It’s one thing to say magazine content will always be more special and better, but will they? I love reading magazines as well, but more each day I substitute with blogs like this. And if magazines want to go more digital and real-time, they’ll have to substitute quality which could impair their differentiation. Magazines are losing money every day because brands and advertisers are going direct to blogs. This we know. So it’s not about slightly better content because they won’t generate enough money to support themselves with slightly better content. They will have to evolve their model drastically and thus far, there is no indication that they are doing this. They will likely continue trying to be a super-blog — employing the best writers and editors to build a credible brand — or migrate to something very different.

Reply
Ali Smith July 10, 2013

My fave blogger at the moment

A Stylish Escape, by Rebecca Martin, love it………….

Reply
KalkiFashion January 10, 2015

Hey I read your blog, this is really amazing and superior subject of conversation you quarry. I completely agree with this blog. Thank s for discussion of this great topic.

Thank s

Reply
probe97 January 15, 2015

I feel that fashion magazines will not faid away because most readers love the feel and presents of those sweet scented glossy pages displaying gorgeous colourful topics projecting photo’sand stories towards their readers sending them into a world of femine fantasy.

Reply
maqsood godil August 28, 2016

Hi, it is certainly incredible and excellent topic. I personally feel that that fashion magazines will never disappear because of their professionalism. Their teamwork and professional approach always grants all in one. I can see revolution in both ends; ultimately people will get much better topics. pictures and quality of photographs than what they are getting.
Your blog has forced to add it in favorite bookmark.

Reply
Fashionist World October 22, 2016

Great article and well written.
Cheers for extra efforts!
I think E-Magazines will take place for physical magazine. There is no competition for readers as they both have their own followers.
Many thanks.

Reply